If you are a piano student or recreational player wanting a good accurate and weighted piano key action in a digital piano, I do not recommend the Yamaha YPG535 ($499 internet discount price - left pic) because it does not have the weighted key movement. Yamaha is a great piano company and makes many different models of acoustic & digital pianos, but the YPG535 is really a glorified keyboard with 88-keys. Although the keys themselves look similar to a piano key shape, they actually have the same key movement and feel as a Yamaha 61 or 76-key keyboard which have the lightweight spring-type key actions. The YPG535 is, however, an enjoyable instrument to play just for fun because it has lots of very nice sounds, drum rhythms, chord arrangements, recording features and other fun things that make it a cool instrument to own for both young people and adults. It even sounds somewhat (but not actually) like a piano so it would appear to be a good low priced digital piano. But as far as a realistic weighted piano key touch and acoustic piano resonating tone and dynamics...it's not even close to the real thing and it was not designed to be that way.
Yamaha calls their YPG535 key action a graded soft touch keyboard and that would be true. It's very easy to press the white keys (except for the black keys which are much harder to press because of the stiffer spring mechanism), and that is not what you want if you are interested in developing good piano playing habits and skills. Not only is the key action not a good one for duplicating an acoustic piano touch, but the key polyphony memory (especially useful when playing larger passages of music or layering instrument sounds together) is a low 32-notes which is very outdated technology, but is cheaper price to produce. Normal polyphony memory these days is somewhere between 64 to128 notes in lower priced digital pianos. Also, if you are using the regular acoustic piano tone, it starts sounding like an electric piano as you get nearer to the top octaves. In other words, the piano doesn't reproduce a realistic piano tone in the upper octaves (it's better in the lower octaves) and that's due to the less expensive sound sampling technology in this model.
Also, the piano sound itself has minimal dynamic range (changes in the tone like on acoustic pianos) when trying to get softer mellower tone on up to bright resonate tone when playing at different finger pressure on the keys. When you're progressing as a piano student (or if you already play) more polyphony memory and better dynamic range is needed for playing at a higher skill level of music including using the piano sustain pedal. The minimum polyphony in any digital piano should be at least 64-notes and the preferable polyphony should be closer to 100 notes or more as it is in many other Yamaha digital pianos. If you are and will remain at a beginner skill level, this may not be an issue for you, but hopefully you won't be a beginner forever:)
With regard to the piano pedal, the YPG535 piano only allows the single pedal that comes with it to produce an on & off sustain instead of a graduated (half-pedal) sustaining of notes. This is not the way regular acoustic pianos work and so you should be sure if at all possible that the digital piano you purchase has a "half-pedaling" feature, especially if you hope to go beyond a beginning skill level. Most of the better Yamaha digital pianos do have this feature as well as other good brands including Casio, Kawai, and Roland.
As I mentioned earlier, the Yamaha YPG535 is a fun piano to play, has a cool user interface display (left pic), has good speaker volume, and if you don't care at all about the key action weight and movement being like an acoustic piano or the piano sound being closer to a real piano over the the entire keyboard, then this piano could be a very good option for people who just want lots of cool electronic features, good quality instrument sounds, fun rhythms, interactive user interface, and USB flash drive input and USB output for direct connect to computers.
The better option in a Yamaha digital piano with an upgraded acoustic piano style key action is the DGX640 ($799 discount internet price - includes stand). It has all the cool features (and more) of the YPG535 along with a noticeably more realistic weighted piano key action and much better piano sound. Although it's about $300 more, in my opinion its worth the difference and includes double the key polyphony memory (64-notes, very important). You might also want to check out the Casio Privia PX330 at $699 (discount internet price - stand optional). In my opinion this piano feels even better than the Yamaha DGX640, has a wider dynamic range for piano tonality, and has 128 notes of polyphony which is double the polyphony memory of the Yamaha DGX640 (that's a very good amount of polyphony memory)! However, ultimately either piano would be good to own and lots of fun with many great features.
My goal here is not to list the amount of instrument sounds, rhythms, accompaniments, recording tracks, or other extra features these pianos have because they all do a good job of that. But I want to focus on proper key action movement and piano tone quality & dynamics, which are of primary importance to me and if that's what you are looking for, I would stay away from the YPG535. Be aware that there are always people who will buy these types of pianos and give them good reviews for their touch and tone. However, these people almost always have little to no experience with real acoustic pianos and the way they actually behave when playing them, regardless of what they may say in their consumer reviews.
If you have little or no experience with a digital piano then the YDP535 may seem perfect for you, but in reality could create bad playing habits or hinder your piano playing growth if you use it for very long. It is fine for playing fun or for practicing lessons for a short time, but I would never recommend it to any of my piano students or anyone else wanting a "real piano playing experience." If you want or need an instrument that will allow the student or player to progress in their playing so they can play a piano correctly and adapt easily to a real acoustic piano later down the road (which is a great goal), then I would not recommend the Yamaha YDP535 for that purpose. However, if you want a fun 88-key digital piano instrument and don't really care how the keys respond or move to your finger touch, aren't bothered by the low 32-note polyphony, and are easily satisfied with a basic piano sound like on a 61-key Yamaha keyboard (along with the the fun features), then this will likely be a great instrument for you.
If you want more piano info and LOWER PRICES than internet or store discounts, please email me at tim@azpianowholesale.com or call direct at 602-571-1864.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


What would you recommend between the DGX640 and the Casio PX330?
ReplyDeleteThey really are different pianos with a variety of strengths and abilities for their price range. Either one would be a good choice as I don't really have a preference. It just depends on your musical goals and piano playing experience.
ReplyDelete